A Lesson in Lived Experience
I vividly remember a conversation I had with a fellow soccer coach years ago. She had played at an extremely high level – even training alongside U.S. legend Mia Hamm – and was a director at our club.
She mentioned one of the other directors and dismissed his coaching ability because he hadn’t played at a high level as a youth and never played in college.
“He doesn’t know what it feels like to be in that setting or to play under the pressure of a national team,” she said.
Whether or not that disqualified him as a good coach is debatable, but her words stayed with me.
That conversation stuck because it highlighted an important truth: knowledge is not the same as lived experience. You can read every book about staying calm under pressure, but it’s different when you feel it in your own body, when scouts, coaches, and teammates are all measuring your every move.
I’ve come to realize the same is true for perfectionism. It’s one thing to understand the research; it’s another to live it, day after day.
And this isn’t just about me. Perfectionism is everywhere. I often joke that tying self-worth to achievement is the American way. In fact, research shows it’s rising sharply. One large-scale study found that perfectionism among young people has increased by more than 30% since the late 1980s, with socially prescribed perfectionism — the sense that others expect you to be flawless — climbing the fastest.
The cost is steep: living in a constant state of anxiety, bodies that can’t recover, and relationships stretched thin by impossible expectations. If you’ve ever felt like no matter what you do it’s never enough, or that your body simply can’t keep up with the demands, then you already know the toll perfectionism takes.
My Personal Breaking Point
It wasn’t until graduate school that I fully recognized how perfectionism showed up in my own life. Until then, I thought striving for perfection was a noble goal. But once I learned how it affects the mind, body, and relationships, I realized I was a walking example of it.
I was constantly chasing unrealistic goals, worrying endlessly, beating myself up when I fell short, and never feeling satisfaction even when I succeeded.
It’s a formula that breeds stress, anxiety, rumination, and shame. I tied my worth to achievement, always wondering if I would still be accepted or loved if I failed. To avoid that possibility, I tried to control everything around me. I replayed events over and over — wishing I had said or done things differently to avoid setbacks or repair fractured relationships.
When you’re stuck in that perfectionist loop, there’s no end. There’s always another worry, another obstacle, another mistake waiting to happen.
Eventually, I began to notice how perfectionism-driven stress affected not just my mind, but my body too. My system was stuck on high alert, always scanning for danger. My nervous system never shifted into rest and repair. Add to that my habit of pushing myself to the limit during workouts, and my stress response became completely dysfunctional.
“At its core, perfectionism isn’t about being perfect — it’s about trying to fill a void with achievement.”
Without the ability to recover, my body started to shut down — digestive issues, chronic muscle and joint pain, and a total inability to handle even small stressors in a way that aligned with my values.
I’d always been fit, active, and proud of my physique. Co-workers once nicknamed me “Baywatch Joe.” But when my body couldn’t keep up, it started to mess with my head. I began turning down events I wanted to attend, knowing I’d pay the price physically.
Friends would look at me strangely, trying to convince me to join, and I felt like they thought I was making excuses. I even questioned myself: “Is this just in my head?”
It’s hard to reconcile having a Baywatch body but feeling like it’s held together with duct tape and super glue. Or going to bed earlier than my grandma on a Saturday night, hoping rest would be enough to help me heal.
I share this not to elicit sympathy, but so you know you’re not alone. I know what it feels like when your body is breaking down and doctors don’t have answers. I know what it feels like when specialist after specialist shrugs and says, “You’re probably just sore because you’re active.”
I know what it feels like to be trapped in endless rumination, to believe there’s no way out – when body and mind keep telling me the same thing. That I am broken. I know how it wears down your goals, your relationships, and your sense of worth.
The Path to Healing
But I also know what it feels like to begin pulling out of the spiral. At first it comes in brief flashes — a moment of calm here and there. Then, slowly, those moments expand. I began to notice how my body responded when I stepped out of the thought-induced stress loop. Tension melted. Pain eased. Digestion improved.
To truly break free and heal, fundamental change is necessary. At its core, perfectionism isn’t about being perfect — it’s about trying to fill a void with achievement. It’s about low self-worth and the fear that we aren’t lovable as we are. Healing requires changing how we relate to ourselves: catching our thoughts, reframing our beliefs, and interrupting rumination.
But cognitive change alone isn’t enough. The most powerful healing comes when we pair those shifts with a bottom-up approach. When we signal to the body that it’s safe. When we cultivate presence through breathwork, mindfulness, and gentle, intentional movement.
In that state, the body shifts out of constant danger mode and into recovery. The parasympathetic system turns on, and we finally begin to rest and heal.
It’s not easy. These patterns take years to build, they don’t unravel overnight. But with the right approach, even small shifts can bring noticeable change. And, over time, real healing.
That conversation with my colleague years ago taught me that knowledge and lived experience are not the same. I know this now more than ever with perfectionism. I’ve researched it, I’ve lived it, and I’ve begun to heal it. And my hope is that you see the same is possible for you.








